How to Write Email Subject Lines That Actually Get Opened

Disclosure: I may earn a small commission for purchases made through affiliate links in this post at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I truly believe in. Thank you for supporting my site!

You spent hours crafting the perfect email. The content is valuable, the offer is fantastic, and you hit "send" feeling proud. Then... crickets. A dismal open rate stares back at you. What happened?

The problem likely wasn't your email. It was your subject line.

Think of your subject line as the doorway to your email. You can have the most beautiful, valuable room inside, but if the doorway is plain, confusing, or looks like every other door on the street, no one will bother to open it.

Your subject line is your first impression, your handshake, and your elevator pitch—all rolled into one short line of text.

It’s the single most important factor in determining whether your email gets read or sent straight to the trash.

The good news is that writing great subject lines isn't a mysterious art. It's a science. Let's break down the psychology and practical formulas you can use to make your emails impossible to ignore.

The Psychology of the Inbox: Why Subject Lines Matter

Before we write a single word, we need to understand what's happening in your subscriber's mind when they see your email.

They are busy, distracted, and scrolling quickly. Their inbox is a crowded, noisy place. Your subject line has less than three seconds to answer one burning question: "What's in this for me?"

It’s a quick cost-benefit analysis. The "cost" is their time and attention. The "benefit" is the value or intrigue your subject line promises.

A great subject line does one of three things:

1. Sparks Curiosity: It creates a "knowledge gap" that the reader feels compelled to fill.

2. Promises a Clear Benefit: It directly states how the email will help, entertain, or benefit them.

3. Evokes an Emotion: It makes them feel something—urgency, excitement, fear of missing out (FOMO), or connection.

According to a report by Litmus, 47% of email recipients decide to open an email based on the subject line alone. You're not just writing a title; you're writing a strategic invitation.

The Golden Rules: What to ALWAYS Do

Follow these foundational principles to build a solid base for every subject line you write.

1. Keep it Short and Scannable

Aim for 30-50 characters. Why? Because on mobile devices (where over half of all emails are opened), long subject lines get cut off. You want the entire promise to be visible at a glance.

• Too Long: "Here's the amazing new strategy I just learned for creating high-converting Pinterest pins that actually drive traffic."

• Just Right: "My new Pinterest pin strategy is working"

2. Be Clear, Not Clickbait

Never trick your audience into opening an email. If your subject line says "You won't BELIEVE this!" and the email is about your office hours, you've broken trust. Curiosity should be satisfied, not betrayed.

The content must deliver on the subject line's promise.

3. Use "You" and "Your"

Personalization isn't just about using someone's first name. Using the word "you" makes the subject line feel like a one-on-one conversation. It immediately signals that the content is relevant to the reader.

• It's about you: "A new blog post is live"

• It's about YOU: "Your guide to a better morning is inside"

4. Test, Test, Test!

Your audience is unique. What works for one business might not work for yours. The only way to know for sure is to use your email service provider's A/B testing feature (sometimes called "split testing").

Send one version of a subject line to a small part of your list and another version to another part. See which one wins, and send the winner to the rest of your list.

The 7 Proven Subject Line Formulas (With Examples)

Here are reliable, plug-and-play formulas you can adapt for any email.

Formula 1: The "How-To" + [Desired Result]

This formula works because it promises a clear, achievable outcome.

• Template: "How to [Achieve X] in [Time Frame]"

• Example: "How to write a blog post in 60 minutes"

Formula 2: The "Question" They Are Asking

This taps directly into their internal dialogue and shows you understand them.

• Template: "Struggling with [Common Problem]?"

• Example: "Struggling to find time for your side business?"

Formula 3: The "Number" + "List"

Our brains are naturally drawn to numbered lists because they promise a structured, easy-to-digest piece of content.

• Template: "[Number] Ways to [Solve a Problem]"

• Example: "3 ways to organize your inbox today"

Formula 4: The "Story" Teaser

Humans are wired for stories. A hint of a personal story creates immediate connection and intrigue.

• Template: "Why I stopped [Common Practice]"

• Example: "Why I stopped using Instagram for my business"

Formula 5: The "Secret" or "Little-Known"

This formula leverages curiosity and the desire for "insider" information.

• Template: "The little-known secret to [Achieving a Goal]"

• Example: "The little-known secret to calm mornings"

Formula 6: The "This or That" Question

This is highly engaging because it invites a mental choice. It can also be great for market research.

• Template: "[Option A] or [Option B]: Which is better for you?"

• Example: "Morning routine or evening routine: Which is better for busy moms?"

Formula 7: The "Direct" & Personal

This works best with a segmented list. Using a subscriber's name or referencing a specific action they took feels incredibly personal.

• Template: "[First Name], a question about your [Recent Activity]"

• Example: "Sarah, a quick question about the guide you downloaded"

Tools like CoSchedule's Email Subject Line Tester can help you analyze your subject lines for emotional words and overall strength before you hit send.

Words That Work: Power Words to Boost Opens

Sprinkling in the right words can dramatically increase your subject line's impact. Use these power words strategically.

Curiosity Words: Secret, Behind the Scenes, The truth about, This is why, Have you seen?

Urgency/FOMO Words: Last chance, Ending soon, Final hours, Don't miss out, Today only

Value Words: Free, New, You, Easy, Instant, Save, Gain, Proven, Quick, Because

Personal Words: Your, Inside, For you, Just for you, Me & you

What to AVOID: The Quickest Ways to the Trash Folder

Just as important as knowing what to do is knowing what not to do. Avoid these common pitfalls at all costs.

• Spam Trigger Words: Words like "FREE" (in all caps), "Act Now," "Guaranteed," "No Risk," "Winner," and "Cash" can trigger spam filters and scare off readers. If you use "free," use it in lowercase and contextually, e.g., "My free guide to..."

  
  

• Being Vague or Generic: "Newsletter #5" or "Check this out" gives the reader zero reason to open.

  
  

• Using All Caps: IT LOOKS LIKE YOU'RE SHOUTING. It feels aggressive and is a classic spam tactic.

  
  

• Overusing Symbols and Emojis: A single, relevant emoji can stand out. But too many, like "🔥🚀✨ Your future is HERE!!! ✨🚀🔥" looks unprofessional and spammy.

  
  

As highlighted by Mailchimp's research, clean, authentic subject lines consistently outperform gimmicky ones.

Putting It All Together: Real-World Makeovers

Let's see these formulas in action with some "before and after" examples.

Scenario 1: A business coach is launching a new course.

• Before: "New Course Launch!"

• After: "The one mistake that keeps coaches stuck (and how to fix it)"

Scenario 2: A wellness coach is sharing a blog post.

• Before: "My new blog post on stress"

• After: "Feeling overwhelmed? Try this 2-minute stress reset."

Scenario 3: A creative entrepreneur is offering a discount.

• Before: "20% Off My Templates!"

• After: "Your new Canva templates are waiting inside 🎁"

See the difference? The "after" versions are specific, benefit-driven, and speak directly to the reader's problem or desire.

Your New Subject Line Action Plan

You don't need to be a professional copywriter to write great subject lines. You just need to be intentional.

1. Before you write the email, write the subject line first. This forces you to get clear on the single biggest benefit for the reader.

2. Ask yourself: "If I were my subscriber, why would I care about this?"

3. Pick one formula from the list above and adapt it to your topic.

4. Check it against the "Golden Rules." Is it short, clear, and scannable?

5. Run a simple A/B test on your next email to start learning what your specific audience loves.

Your email content is the gift. Your subject line is the beautifully wrapped package that makes people excited to open it. Stop leaving your gifts in plain, brown boxes. With a little strategy, you can make every subject line an irresistible invitation.